Growing Unusual Root Crops in South Dakota

South Dakota can grow celeriac, kohlrabi, turnips, rutabagas, parsnips, horseradish and Jerusalem artichokes, but the calendar is tight and the winters are hard. Most of these roots go in during May, once the soil has warmed. Celeriac is the one that needs a real season-length check. Horseradish and Jerusalem artichokes are the ones that shrug off the cold. Start with a date, then check it against your own county.

When the soil is warm enough in South Dakota

Root crop seedlings in a spring bed
Four crops, four different planting dates.

Reading the frost date

For the reference city, the last spring frost falls between April 29 and May 9. That comes from the NOAA NCEI 1991-2020 Climate Normals, using the 32°F freeze probabilities (30-70% band) for station USW00014944, an airport weather station. A frost date is a probability, not a promise, so a late freeze after May 9 is possible in any given year.

The airport is also not your garden. Suburban and rural plots typically see the last spring frost later than the airport does, often by one to two weeks, and more at elevation. Treat April 29 to May 9 as the reference-city figure and check the numbers for your own county before you mark a calendar.

Frost is also only a proxy for what these crops want. They wait for warm soil, and soil warms after the frost risk ends, not with it. A bed can be frost-free by early May and still be cold and wet two inches down, where seeds sit. A cheap soil thermometer pushed in at seeding depth tells you more than the date does. Cold-tolerant types (turnips, kohlrabi, horseradish crowns) cope with a cool bed far better than celeriac transplants, which sulk and can bolt if chilled. For the soil-temperature thresholds for each crop, South Dakota State University Extension is the source to trust.

Site the permanent one first

Jerusalem artichoke deserves a warning before any planting advice. Once it is in the ground it is effectively permanent. Every fragment of tuber left behind when you dig will regrow, and a few knobby pieces missed in fall become a thicket the next summer. It is probably the most regretted planting in a vegetable garden. Give it a fenced corner, a bed with hard edges, or a large container sunk in the ground, and keep it away from beds you plan to rotate. Never put it in the middle of the vegetable plot.

Once the site is settled, the growing part is simple. Plant tubers as soon as the soil can be worked in spring. It is tall, so put it where it will not shade the rest. One more fact about the vegetable: it stores inulin rather than starch, and that causes digestive discomfort in many people. A small first portion is the sensible way to find out how you react.

The other roots sort themselves by tolerance. Turnips, kohlrabi and rutabaga can go in around the frost window. Parsnips can follow when the bed has warmed. Celeriac waits the longest, because it also has the longest road to finish.

How long the season lasts here

The same NOAA normals (station USW00014944) give the first fall frost between September 24 and October 4. Put the two sets of dates together and the frost-free window at the reference station runs from roughly 138 days to roughly 158 days. The short end is May 9 to September 24. The long end is April 29 to October 4.

That is a respectable window but not a generous one, and it shrinks in the country. If a rural garden loses one to two weeks at each end, as the station caution suggests, it could have two to four weeks less than those figures. A gardener in a frost pocket or at higher elevation should plan around the short end of the range, not the long one.

Season length matters because of what it allows. A window near 158 days leaves room for a second sowing of the fast roots. Turnips and kohlrabi sown after the first harvest can mature in the cooler weather ahead of the fall frost. A window near 138 days, or less, makes the first sowing the only one for anything slow. At that point you are not planning succession. You are choosing which crops get the early start.

Celeriac is where this gets pointed. It is the longest crop in the group, and direct-sowing it in the garden would use up much of the window before it had a chance to size up. Most gardeners here start it indoors and set out transplants after the frost risk and cold soil are behind them. Transplanting has a cost, since roots are disturbed and a check in growth can follow, but with a window this size it is usually worth it for celeriac. Taproots like parsnips are a different case. They resent being moved and are better sown where they will grow.

To work backward from fall, count from your own first-frost estimate, not the airport’s. Set a second-sowing date that leaves the crop enough weeks to finish before the freeze. The succession sowing guide on this site walks through that countdown step by step.

Heat and water in South Dakota

Frost on the leaves of a root crop
Which can stay in the ground is a local fact.

What the summer numbers are, and are not

For your location, pull the NOAA climate normals for the nearest station, or ask your county extension office.

Roots that get uneven water tend to split or turn woody, and heat at the root zone slows many of them. A layer of mulch holds moisture and keeps soil cooler. Some shade at the root, from mulch or from taller neighbors, helps in a hot spell. In a cool, damp summer the problems shift to mildew, slow ripening and rot, and airflow and spacing matter more than irrigation.

Winter decides the rest

Two facts govern this group, and the first is season length. It tells you whether celeriac can finish at all. The reference-station window of 138 to 158 days makes it feasible with transplants. A cold, late-spring garden may not get there.

The second is winter cold. At the reference station of Sioux Falls, the mean daily minimum of the coldest month is 8.5°F (NOAA NCEI Climate Normals 1991-2020). That is an average of the nightly lows, not the record low, so individual nights run colder. The USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map 2023 puts the state across zones 3b to 5b. Those zones are built on a different variable, the average annual extreme minimum, and they cover a range, so your county may sit anywhere in it.

Horseradish and Jerusalem artichokes are perennials that generally overwinter in cold ground, which is partly why the artichoke is so hard to remove. Hardy roots such as parsnips and rutabagas can be left in place under a deep mulch of straw or leaves. Even so, the soil can freeze hard enough to make digging difficult, so many gardeners lift a portion before the ground locks up. Celeriac is less forgiving and should come out before a hard freeze.

Anything you store needs inspection, not trust. Check each root for a soft patch, a weeping spot or a moldy crown. Any of those ends the question, and a root that looks sound on the outside is not proven safe. Discard what shows them, and do not promise yourself a keeping time for what is left.

Which these root crops suit South Dakota

The choice here is by type. A short or uncertain season favors the earliest-maturing types. A hot summer favors roots that get airflow and shade at the soil line. A humid or wet one makes disease resistance the first criterion on the seed packet.

Crop type How it fits the season Winter in the ground
Turnips, kohlrabi Quick types; suit a first sowing and a fall repeat Plan to harvest; do not count on winter survival
Rutabaga Slower than turnips, still workable with an early start Can be mulched, but check for soft spots
Parsnip Sown in place once soil warms; slow to germinate Often mulched; soil may freeze hard
Celeriac Longest season; needs transplants Lift before a hard freeze
Horseradish Perennial; sited once Generally stays in the ground
Jerusalem artichoke Perennial; permanent once planted Generally stays in the ground

The cultivars that perform here are the ones trialled in South Dakota soil and weather. A name borrowed from a seed catalog or another state is a guess. South Dakota State University Extension is where locally tested recommendations live, and they are the only ones worth buying seed against.

Two cautions carry across the group. Turnips, rutabagas and kohlrabi are brassicas, so they share pests and diseases with cabbage, kale and mustard. A gardener who rotates them into a bed where cabbage grew last year has rotated nothing. Count them as one family when you plan rotation.

Horseradish needs a separate warning when you turn to the kitchen. Grating a fresh root releases compounds that burn the eyes and airways, and the effect is real, not a joke. Work with a window open or a fan running, and keep your face well back from the bowl.

For readers comparing the cold-climate picture, the Celeriac, Kohlrabi, Horseradish and Jerusalem Artichokes guide covers each crop in depth. Neighboring-climate notes are in Growing Unusual Root Crops in Idaho and Growing Unusual Root Crops in Maine.

Common questions

Which frost date should I use for my garden?

Start with April 29 to May 9, the last-frost range for the reference airport station, and then add time. Suburban and rural gardens often see the last frost one to two weeks later. Your county extension office can give a closer figure.

Can I leave roots in the ground over a South Dakota winter?

Horseradish and Jerusalem artichokes generally stay put. Hardy roots like parsnips and rutabagas can be mulched deeply, but frozen soil can make digging hard. Celeriac should be lifted before a hard freeze. Inspect everything you dig for soft patches, weeping spots or moldy crowns.

Is celeriac realistic here?

At the reference station the frost-free window runs roughly 138 to 158 days, which is workable with transplants started indoors. A rural or higher-elevation garden may have two to four weeks less, and that is where celeriac gets risky.

Which varieties should I buy?

South Dakota State University Extension can point you to the varieties tested in the state.