Four diseases are the main ones for roses in South Dakota: black spot, powdery mildew, downy mildew and rose rosette. The first three are caused by fungi or fungus-like organisms, and they follow the weather closely, which swings between hot, stormy days and cool nights. Rose rosette is a virus carried by a microscopic mite, and it is the only one of the four that ends with a shovel. For basic care, see growing roses in South Dakota.
Which rose diseases South Dakota’s climate brings
Summers on the northern Plains are warm, with thunderstorms that can drop a lot of rain in an hour, followed by evenings that cool off fast. The eastern part of the state gets noticeably more rain than the western part, so leaf diseases that depend on moisture hit hardest in the east. Which disease dominates in any one year depends on the pattern of that summer: a wet July favors one, a dry August with cold nights favors another.
Black spot, caused by the fungus Diplocarpon rosae, shows up as round black spots with feathery edges on the upper side of the leaf, usually ringed by a yellow halo. Affected leaves yellow and fall, starting at the bottom of the plant and moving up. The spores need liquid water sitting on the leaf, and they travel by rain splash, so a run of warm, wet weather drives outbreaks. The fungus survives winter on fallen leaves and on infected canes, which is why bagging fallen leaves in fall matters: leave them under the bush and the fungus restarts from the same litter next spring. Home compost piles rarely get hot enough to kill it, so the leaves go in the trash.
Powdery mildew covers new leaves, buds and young stems with a white to gray powder that wipes off with a finger. Leaves beneath it curl, thicken and turn purplish. Unlike most leaf fungi, it does not need wet leaves to infect. It thrives when days are warm and dry and nights are cool and humid, which describes much of late summer here.
Downy mildew prefers the opposite: cool, wet, humid weather. It produces purplish-red to brown blotches with angular edges, bounded by the leaf veins. The top of the leaf has no white powder at all. In humid conditions a thin gray fuzz may form on the underside. Leaves can yellow and drop within a few days of the first blotches, which makes it look sudden, and the plant can be half bare before you work out what happened.
When each one shows up here
The disease calendar runs between the last spring freeze and the first fall freeze. NOAA NCEI climate normals for the Sioux Falls airport station put the median last spring freeze (32°F) around May 1, with freezes still possible into mid-May in some years, and the median first fall freeze around October 6. Gardens outside town can see the last spring frost later and the first fall frost earlier than the airport, and the gap grows with elevation, as in the Black Hills. Shift every timing below to match your own garden.
Roses leaf out in late April to mid-May, and the first disease to appear is downy mildew, but only when spring is cool and wet. You will see purple-brown blotches on the first set of leaves before the weather warms. In a normal spring it fades as temperatures climb. Black spot starts a little later, in early summer, once warm weather and rain arrive together. The first sign is a few small black spots on the lowest leaves, the ones closest to splashing soil. Powdery mildew can start in June as well, as white patches on soft new growth, in spots where nights stay cool.
Black spot climbs the plant through July and August, with each round of storms pushing it higher. By late August a badly hit rose can be bare from the knees down, with yellowing leaves higher up. Powdery mildew is heaviest on late-summer growth in August and September, when days are still warm and nights have started to cool. A cool, damp stretch in September can bring downy mildew back before frost ends the season. Once the leaves drop, the infected ones carry the black spot fungus through winter, which makes fall cleanup the last step in the disease calendar.
What this changes about spacing and watering
All three leaf diseases depend on moisture or stagnant air, so the defence is air movement and dry foliage. Black spot and downy mildew need the leaf surface wet. Powdery mildew builds in still, humid pockets around the plant. Plains wind helps you here, and a rose tucked into a corner behind a solid fence loses that help. Keep roses clear of walls and solid fences, and open the center of each bush when you prune in spring so air can pass through.
Spacing between plants depends on the mature size of the rose:
| Type of rose | Spacing between plants |
|---|---|
| Hybrid teas and floribundas | 3 feet |
| Compact shrub roses | 3 to 4 feet |
| Large shrub roses and old garden roses | 4 to 5 feet |
Plants crowded closer than this stay damp longer after every rain and spread spores from leaf to leaf. Don’t plant a groundcover or perennials right up against the canes either.
Water at the base, with a soaker hose or drip line, and skip overhead sprinklers, which wet the leaves and splash spores upward. Water in the early morning so sun and wind dry any splash before afternoon. Evening watering leaves foliage wet through a cool night, which suits black spot and downy mildew. In dry spells, soak deeply rather than sprinkling a little every day. A layer of shredded bark mulch keeps soil from splashing onto the lower leaves. Pull it back from the base of the canes.
Rose rosette: the one that means digging the plant up
Rose rosette is caused by a virus carried by a tiny eriophyid mite, Phyllocoptes fructiphilus, which is too small to see without magnification and drifts on the wind from plant to plant. The disease is spreading north through the Great Plains, and a rose in South Dakota that shows the symptoms below should be treated as a suspected case until it is confirmed. It is the most serious problem on this list because no spray, fungicide or miticide cures it.
The first sign is usually a cluster of thin, dense shoots at the end of a cane, called a witches’ broom. The shoots are often deep red or pink, and the leaves are small and crumpled. Canes can grow unusually thick and fast, and they carry far more thorns than normal. Flowers, if they form, are distorted. The plant declines and usually dies.
In farm country, drift from broadleaf herbicides can twist and strap rose leaves too. Herbicide damage tends to hit neighboring plants as well, and the new growth lacks the dense bunching and the crowd of thorns that mark rosette. If the shoots look like a broom and the thorns are packed, assume rosette.
Cutting off the affected cane does not save the plant, because the virus has already spread through it. Dig out the whole plant, roots included, since leftover root pieces can send up infected shoots. Bag the plant before carrying it across the yard so mites are not shaken loose, and put it in the trash, never the compost.
Checking this against your own county
Disease timing and pressure shift from one county to the next. USDA hardiness zones across the state run from 3b to 5b on the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map, and rainfall changes as you move from the east to the west. The frost windows above are for the Sioux Falls airport, so adjust them for your own garden. For a diagnosis, take photos or a leaf sample to South Dakota State University Extension: the South Dakota State University Extension staff can identify the problem and tell you what has been confirmed near you, which matters most for a suspected case of rose rosette.
Common questions
When should I start fungicide for black spot? A fungicide protects healthy leaves but does not heal spots already there, so it works best when applied before symptoms appear. Start at leaf-out in spring and follow the label on a product listed for roses. Cleaning up fallen leaves and watering at the base lower the pressure enough that many gardeners need few sprays.
Does a hard winter kill black spot? Cold does not clear it reliably. The fungus survives on fallen leaves and on infected canes, and snow cover can insulate both. Raking and bagging leaves in fall and cutting out spotted canes at pruning are the steps that reduce next year’s start.
Will black spot kill my rose? It rarely kills one outright. Early and repeated leaf loss weakens the plant, though, and a weakened rose handles winter and the following spring less well. Keep the leaves on through summer with good spacing and dry foliage.
Does a dry summer mean I can skip disease worries? Black spot slows without rain and wet leaves, but powdery mildew does not need either. Hot, dry days followed by cool nights suit it well, so check new growth for white powder in August and September even in a dry year.