Protecting Roses Through a South Dakota Winter

Grafted roses such as hybrid teas, floribundas and grandifloras need a mound of soil over the crown every winter anywhere in South Dakota. The mound goes on after the ground begins to freeze, and it comes off in stages in spring. Own-root shrub roses bred for the northern plains often need little or nothing once established. The sections below cover who needs protection, the timing, the depth, and the common methods that do harm. For the basics of growing roses in South Dakota, start with the main guide.

Do roses need winter protection in South Dakota?

The USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map places most of South Dakota in zones 4a to 5b. That system rates a place by one number, the average annual extreme minimum temperature. Even the warmest zone 5b pockets in the south see winter lows well below zero Fahrenheit in a typical year. The coldest northern and high-elevation areas fall in zone 4a or colder, where lows run colder still.

What matters for a rose is the graft union. On a grafted rose, this knob at the base of the canes is where the named cultivar was joined to a hardier rootstock. If the canes die back, the plant can regrow from the union. If the union freezes, the rootstock sends up its own growth, usually a different and less showy rose than the one you bought. That is the loss mounding prevents.

Temperature is only half of it. Prairie winters bring dry wind that strips moisture from canes, and thaw-and-refreeze swings that heave shallow roots. Open ground can lose its snow cover to wind, so the insulation you counted on isn’t guaranteed. Protection is a hedge against all three.

The honest answer varies by rose type. Here is how it sorts out.

Rose type Zones 4a to 4b (northern and higher ground) Zone 5a to 5b (warmest southern pockets)
Grafted hybrid tea, floribunda, grandiflora Mound every winter Mound every winter
Own-root cold-hardy shrub roses Mound for the first two winters, then judge by dieback Usually none needed once established
Rugosa roses Usually none None
Climbers Lay canes down and cover them Lay canes down and cover them

Which cold-hardy roses earn that lighter treatment is covered in Roses That Hold Up in South Dakota.

When to start, and what triggers it

The trigger is a run of hard freezes, and the calendar only approximates it. Mound too early and the plant is still taking in warmth and sap, so the buried crown stays damp and mild. That invites rot and gives mice and voles a cozy place to nest. The roses need to go fully dormant first, and for most of South Dakota that means late October to early November.

Use the first frost only as a warning. At the Sioux Falls airport station, NOAA NCEI climate normals put the median first fall 32 F freeze around October 6, with about one year in ten seeing it before September 23. Roses shrug off that first frost. Gardens outside town can see it earlier than the airport, and more so at elevation, such as in the Black Hills. Even so, a light frost is weeks too early to mound.

Look at the plant and the ground instead. Leaves should be yellowing or dropped, and new growth should have stopped. The soil surface should be crusty or frozen in the morning after several nights in a row of hard freezing temperatures. Days can still thaw. A cold snap of one or two nights doesn’t count.

Preparation starts in late summer. Stop fertilizing roses after midsummer, since late nitrogen pushes soft growth that won’t harden before winter. Stop deadheading as fall approaches so the plant senses the season turning. Water deeply every week or two if fall has been dry, because roses going into frozen ground thirsty suffer more cane dieback. Spring uncovering follows the same logic in reverse. The median last spring 32 F freeze at the same airport station is about May 1, with a freeze after May 14 in roughly one year in ten, and gardens outside town can run later, so take the mound off gradually and keep material nearby for cold nights.

How to mound, and how deep

The goal is to bury the base of the plant, where the graft union sits, and leave the upper canes to take their chances. Canes can die back and still be pruned away in spring. The crown can’t be replaced. Once the ground has frozen on the surface, follow these steps.

  1. Strip the remaining leaves and any fallen foliage from around the plant, and throw them in the trash rather than the compost pile. Diseased leaves left in place carry black spot spores through winter.
  2. Tie the canes together loosely with twine, and trim any that stand much above knee height so they don’t whip in the wind. Save the real pruning for spring, as described in When to Prune Roses in South Dakota.
  3. Cover the graft union with bagged soil, mounded about 10 to 12 inches high and shaped into a cone that reaches up the canes.
  4. After the ground freezes hard, add a loose layer of straw, shredded leaves or evergreen boughs over the cone to hold snow and keep the soil from thawing and refreezing.
  5. For climbers, bend the canes down, pin them to the ground and cover them with soil and straw the same way.

The temptation is to scoop soil from the bed beside the rose. That digs up feeder roots near the crown, and it leaves a shallow trench that collects meltwater and freezes into ice. Soil from the bed can also carry disease spores. Bagged topsoil, garden soil or a compost and soil blend arrives clean and loose. Buy it in late summer, and keep the bags in the garage so you have dry, thawed soil when you need it. Soil that sat outdoors in rain and freezes into a block can’t be shaped around the canes.

Where voles are a problem, wrap a collar of hardware cloth around the mound before adding straw. A rodent nest at the crown can do as much damage as cold.

What does not work in this climate

Three common methods look protective and cause trouble in a climate with sunny winter days and hard nights. Each fails for a specific reason.

  • Plastic wrapping holds moisture against the canes. On a sunny day in January the wrap heats up and the canes warm with it, then freeze solid again at night. The swings split bark, and trapped moisture breeds cane rot and gray mold.
  • A rose cone left sealed behaves the same way. Foam cones turn into small greenhouses on sunny days, so the plant breaks dormancy early, and the inside stays damp. Cones also tip over in prairie wind. If you use one, cut vent holes and put it over a soil mound, not in place of one.
  • Mulch piled while the ground is still warm keeps the crown from going dormant and gives mice and voles shelter. Pile straw or leaves directly against the canes in October and it becomes a nest before it becomes insulation.

Whole leaves have the same problem on a smaller scale. Maple and cottonwood leaves mat down into a wet layer that holds water against the plant. Shred them first or use straw. Whichever material you choose, mound only after the soil surface has frozen, because everything above depends on that sequence. Mounding early is a mistake that careful soil or straw added later will not undo.

Checking this against your own county

The frost dates here come from a single airport weather station, and winter varies a great deal across the state. A garden on a river bottom, a hilltop in the Black Hills and a farmstead in the northeast corner can differ by weeks in when the ground freezes. Higher elevation brings earlier frost, later thaw and colder lows. Call or visit your county office of South Dakota State University Extension (see South Dakota State University Extension) and ask when the ground typically freezes and thaws near you. Use the 32 F frost data for the Sioux Falls station as a reference for the southeast, then adjust for where you live. The latest normals for that station are posted by NOAA NCEI.

Common questions

Should I cut roses back hard before winter?

No. Trim only the tallest canes to about knee height so wind doesn’t whip them loose. Cutting hard in fall removes buds that might otherwise survive and invites dieback at the cut. Do the real pruning in spring, once you can see which canes are alive.

Can I use leaves or straw alone instead of soil?

Loose straw or shredded leaves alone are weaker than soil, because they hold moisture and give rodents a nest while the crown sits exposed. Soil buries the graft union, and straw or leaves go on top to hold snow. Evergreen boughs do the same job and shed water better than leaves.

When does the mound come off?

In stages during spring, as the soil thaws and buds begin to swell. Pull back the straw first, then take off about half the soil, then the rest a week or so later. Keep straw and a sheet or frost cloth nearby until the spring frost window has passed.

Do roses need watering in winter?

A deep soak every week or two in fall, until the ground freezes, helps when autumn has been dry. Once the soil is frozen, skip watering. In a winter with long thaws and no snow, a gentle drink on a mild afternoon can help, as long as the water drains away before nightfall.